Accepted Without Revision, Examples: Some re-writing is needed It is very rare for a manuscript to be accepted without any required revisions. " The remaining 40 fell into the "revise and resubmit" or "major revision" or some similar category. In cases where the work was felt to be of high quality, papers can sometimes be accepted without further review, but if there were serious criticisms, the editors will consider them in making the For some reason I thought the options were to be accepted, accepted with minor revisions, accepted with major revisions, or rejected. 307 Proposal revisions. I was initially confused, did not Some participants report that it is extremely rare for papers to be accepted without revisions, suggesting that even well-established authors typically face at least minor revisions. 小木虫,论坛,科研 应《网络安全法》要求，自2017年10月1日起，未进行实名认证将不得使用互联网跟帖服务。为保障您的帐号能够正常使用，请尽快对帐号进行手机号验证，感谢您的理解与支持！ 本人前不久在爱思维尔上的一个SCI期刊投了一篇文章，10月6日投稿，状态一直是with editor, 今天状态突然变成了accept without revision，编辑发来邮件让我提交一下文章源文件及文章中的相关图片，请问大家有过这种状态吗？ accept without revision 是不是意味着录用了呢？ WASHINGTON — As House Republicans scramble to corral the votes to pass a massive bill for President Donald Trump's agenda, their Senate counterparts are making clear the emerging package won’t 1）原稿接受，无需修改（Publish without changes）：罕见 邮件内容通常如下： Normally, the pre-publication process take… Accept without revision: Very rarely, an article will be accepted for publication without any revisions requested. Typically authors are given a deadline for submitting revisions. Accept, reject, or hide changes made by others working in the file. Minor Revision - A limited number of changes are required. For papers with significant revisions, the editor may choose to send the article back out for peer review. 7万 次浏览 热门 稿件状态 Moderate revision 审稿决定“Moderate revision“意味着你的论文很有可能被录用，但需要做出额外的修改，以满足审稿人的意见。 这些修改通常比“Minor revision”需要更多的时间，通常会给你两到四周的时间把修改过的文章修回给投稿期刊，但同样会因为期刊而异。 Scientists ensure that the scientific results that are published are honest and truthful through the peer review process. Roughly five were accept without revision. Category 2 means that the manuscript will be considered for publication after incorporation of suggested revisions. Since those are the things you hear other people talking about. I'd say maybe 40 were "minor revision. Some variations to this theme are discussed below: Desk rejection: This occurs when an article has been rejected outright by the editor-in-chief, usually without being sent for peer review. Aug 29, 2025 · Very few articles are accepted without revisions. I submitted a paper to a peer-reviewed journal and heard back two months later, with my paper being accepted without revisions (not received any reviewer comments). > 教师之家 (29) > 公派出国 (23) > 找工作 (14) > SciFinder/Reaxys (13) 小木虫论坛-学术科研互动平台 » 学术交流区 » 论文投稿 » 投稿求助 » 收到Accept pending requirements然后decision是accept without revisions之后做什么 相关版块跳转 论文投稿 我要订阅楼主 xiachuyu 的主题更新 Your article has been accepted but they want you to make additional revisions based on criticism about inconsequential language from an assistant editor who doesn’t really know anything about your topic and may not speak English as a first language. One, is there a way to accept all the changes at once and be done with it? Two, is there a way to simply open my document and not have to deal with accepting where declining changes at all. The revised article will be sent back to the reviewers. The most likely outcome is that you will be asked to make minor revisions, and then your school will have some procedure to handle this time-wise. Congratulations Dr. 接收（Accepted with or without minor revision） 除少数杂志外，绝大多数杂志，尤其高质量的杂志，不会“直接接受 (Accept as it is)”第一次投稿的论文。 Decision Types Accept - No further revision required. - Few; Much; Little; Every 请教一下，IEEE期刊，经过两轮后是accept with mandatory minor revisions 返回审稿人么？ It is uncommon for a paper to be accepted for publication without changes – most papers have at least some revisions. Acceptance Without Revisions (Accept as Is) This is a rare and significant achievement that indicates your manuscript has been fully recognized for its exceptional quality and contribution to the field. Once the feedback has been received, the Associate Editor determines whether to reject the manuscript, accept without revision, or return it to the authors for revision (multiple times if necessary). Most of the time, "major revision" seems to be the best verdict in the first round of review. e. (a) If an offeror ’s proposal is eliminated or otherwise removed from the competitive range, no further revisions to that offeror ’s proposal shall be accepted or considered. Article withdrawal Articles-in-Press which represent early versions of articles that have been accepted for publication but not yet published in their final form may be withdrawn prior to final publication. Revisions Required: The submission will be accepted after minor changes have been made. lbl604的个人资料 ,科学网 Archiver | 手机版 | 科学网 ( 京ICP备07017567号-12 ) GMT+8, 2026-1-24 02:46 Revise your manuscript based on the feedback and the new journal’s guidelines before resubmitting. Participants share personal experiences and insights related to the peer-review process across various scientific fields. If an article needs major revision, will it be reviewed again? How do these translate into chances of the article being accepted? 审稿人在提交完这些意见后评审结束（Paper Review Completed），上图中 Completed Assignments 后面就会 +1，表示一项审稿任务完成。 主编或副主编收集并根据所有审稿人的意见给出 接收（Accept） 、 小修（Minor Revisions） 、 大修（Major Revisions） 、 拒稿（Reject） 的决定。 Accept or reject tracked changes and revisions one at a time or all at once. Accepted pending changes (i. PEER REVIEW DECISIONS Paper accepted without any revisions: Very rarely occurs Accepted pending minor revisions: Usually minor edits and/or formatting Accepted pending major revisions: Usually includes dataset or methodology revisions and/or major rewriting After all, the famous saying is “publish or perish. The word "accepted" is usually not included in the decision letter unless the editor has decided to accept the manuscript in its current form without asking for further revision. Am I missing something? 应《网络安全法》要求，自2017年10月1日起，未进行实名认证将不得使用互联网跟帖服务。为保障您的帐号能够正常使用，请尽快对帐号进行手机号验证，感谢您的理解与支持！ 117 I would most readily assume that a paper accepted without revisions went through some fairly lackadaisical peer review rather than being so perfect that experts in the field couldn't find a single thing wrong with it. ” If all of your submitted manuscripts have been accepted straightaway without revision, you are one of the lucky few who no longer need to continue reading. minor revision or major revision) means that you have to perform the requested changes before the paper may be accepted. Implies that the editors and reviewers feel the paper is publishable once their comments have been addressed. Major revision Your article has a chance of being accepted, but the reviewers have requested substantial changes to be made. After submitting their manuscripts to academic journals, authors receive one of several editorial decisions: 'desk reject', 'revise and resubmit', 'major revisions', 'minor revisions', or 'paper accepted. The editor will routinely send manuscripts with such reviews to additional reviewers, who in turn, have been known to return the recommendations of “accept” and “major revision”. May 3, 2013 · The discussion centers around the frequency and circumstances under which submitted academic papers are accepted for publication without requiring revisions. I am so happy but also surprised (and honestly worried) because I recently read that getting a paper accepted without revision is quite rare. Instances of this decision are also rather rare. It is too small of a number to really consider. Click on the “Accept” dropdown in the “Changes” group and choose “Accept All Changes. 4. Anyways, you should still receive some comments, even if it is just a "great manuscript, well done!". Accept with minor revision 基本同上，只是已经确定接受文章。 还有最后一个 16. Remember, it is very rare that a paper will be accepted without any form of revisions requested. Follow the steps below: 1. In the best journal in my field, they have accepted just 2 papers without revision in almost 30 years (~300 papers a year is typical for this journal). If an editor thinks authors need more time than a major revision decision would allow, they should use the “revise and resubmit” option. 査読結果は、概ね以下のパターンのいずれかが考えられます ①Accept without revision（修正の必要なく受理） 非常に稀なケースですが、投稿原稿が修正の必要なくAcceptとなることがあります。 About The Yellow Book Auditors of government entities and entities that receive government awards use our Government Auditing Standards, commonly referred to as generally accepted government auditing standards (GAGAS) or the Yellow Book, to perform their audits and produce their reports. Bassam. Contents The meaning of a 'desk-rejected' paperWhat to do if your paper is desk-rejectedThe meaning of 'revise and However, sometimes the reviewers’ opinions will diverge, with one recommending minor revision with the other recommending rejection. Conditional acceptance pending major revision: Once the article has been revised, it may be sent out for peer review again to the same or different reviewers. Most well-written manuscripts with high-quality illustrations fall into this category. 小修后接受（accept with minor revisions）：亦称为有条件接受，这表示论文需要进行一些小幅度的修改后方能接受，这个决定也不是非常常见，收到这个决定的论文，可能不需要再经历审稿，通常期刊编辑会自己审阅核准，不过，作者必须要记得“小修后发表” 不 In general, I would like to know what goes in the editor's mind when he suggests minor revision/ major revision etc. However, it is good to remember that an ‘accept with minor revisions’ decision does not guarantee acceptance. Being asked to revise your work is a foundational practice in scholarly publishing, and often results in the work being stronger after it has undergone review. It would be extraordinarily rare to be accepted for publication without revision of some sort. Or, just decline the paper. When a paper receives a minor revision decision, it might not be sent for a second round of peer review; usually, the editor goes through the revisions and gives a final approval. The ease of getting a paper published is rarely an indicator of its quality. [RA-L 2025 Accept without Revision] A stereo visual-inertial odometry system based on voxel map - ZikangYuan/voxel_svio Below is an overview of what can be expected with the most common peer review decisions. I suppose it depends on field, but I always look at a R&R as an acceptance (eventually). The majority of articles require revision before reaching this stage. It is the job of the editor and reviewer to make sure that the published papers are scientifically sound, factual, clear and complete. These changes are expected to take significantly longer and we will allow a longer deadline for you to submit. Since peer review is confidential, you also must not share information about the review with anyone without permission from the editors and authors. I'd like to think that my papers that went through revisions before publication are better papers because of it. Resubmit for Review: The submission needs to be re-worked, but with significant changes, may be accepted. Did you ever get a paper accepted by a journal without any comment at all? It has happened to me twice; both times with a very high-standing journal in my field. The manuscript is publishable in its current form. If a revision is successful in addressing reviewer feedback, the manuscript will ultimately be accepted for publication by the journal. It is more likely that it is an indicator of the quality of peer review. My experience is that examiners will prefer to hold their noses and accept a marginal or bad thesis rather than cause trouble and reject the submission. What are the chances of a paper to be accepted if the editor mails that it needs major revisions with reviewers' comments? Journal, Manuscript, Publication How to Accept All Track Changes in Word and Stop Tracking If you want to approve all the suggested edits and revisions made to the document, Word offers you a feature to Accept Changes directly. Minor revisions might include: Accept Submission with minor revisions: Article is accepted for publication assuming the author makes minor revisions as requested by the editor. Articles-in-Press may be withdrawn where: Be polite, structure your response letter so that you thank the editor and reviewers for the time they have spent with your paper, and then clearly explain how you have addressed the ‘major revisions’ deemed necessary for your paper to have a chance to get accepted in your target journal. The requested revisions may be included either in the body of the acceptance message or in an attached file (such as a tracked-changes version of the native MS Word file). . Very few articles are accepted without revisions. Editor Decision choices include: Accept Submission: The submission will be accepted without revisions. (b) The contracting officer may request or allow proposal revisions to clarify and document understandings reached during negotiations. The majority of authors, however, have had manuscript submissions that resulted in some form of rejection. Question: ______ of the proposals presented by the committee were accepted without any revisions. Minor revisions needed: The article is mostly sound, but with some small changes required to the argument, interpretation of the results, or references. 没有任何修改要求，投稿状态有可能直接变成 Decision in process 吗？ | 意得辑专家视点 Editage Insights 答疑论坛 1. Accept without change: This is a very rare decision. ' Learn what these editorial decisions precisely mean, and how to react. It will require a second round of review, however. There is still no guarantee of acceptance at this stage but the chances are certainly higher than at initial submission. Acceptance without revision is very rare, especially for a manuscript that was rejected previously (unless maybe if it was desk rejected because you sent it to a journal that wasn't a good fit). There are really only three possible outcomes once your article has been submitted: accept, reject or revise. Confidential material If you accept, you must treat the materials you receive as confidential documents. Accept：恭喜，编辑对该文章十分满意，决定接受稿件，皆大欢喜的结局。 是这个状态的话，咱们就把悬着的心放下来，出去喊朋友搓一顿庆祝一下吧。 How to track changes in Word using revision marks. One participant mentions that the acceptance rate for major journals is around 50-60%, with only a small percentage of papers requiring just a single round of review. Nov 13, 2023 · Do NOT add a remark that a paper was accepted "without revisions" to any of your application documents. This means you can’t share them with anyone without prior authorization from the editor. Minor revision might be a few weeks, major revisions might be a month or two. Generally, reviewer comments are there to strengthen the paper's quality, your research, or both. 15. Learn more about this process and what you should look for. ” How to use track changes in Word To provide feedback in the document without altering the text, select the text you wish to comment on using your mouse, then click on “New Comment” located in the “Review” tab. I have nearly the same situation, but my manuscript was accepted after submitting the revision (moderate revision) and no further reviewing was needed. Once accepted, the modifications become a permanent part of the document and all associated markups are removed. tvt1r, 6g43br, owquma, fv8zf, hj9aj, ttjl7, pactv, buu7, hppu46, 0dz3,